Is buying or renting better?

People get mad at me whenever I mention renting or buying. I’ll say something like “In addition to the mortgage payment, there are costs associated with owning a home.” And people say “YOU’RE AN IDIOT, RENTING ISN’T BETTER!!!!” Well, I didn’t say renting was better. But I can’t really contest the idiot thing. I mean, how does someone know if they themself is an idiot?! ‎

But this whole rent vs buy thing really misses the point. Too often it’s looked at it in a vacuum. “If you live in the same home for 30 years you’re better off buying that home then renting that exact home.” Well, yeah. Of course. But guess what. That’s not how real life works. Here’s how real life usually goes: You’re living in an apartment, paying pretty cheap rent. And you’re sick of “throwing your money away on rent” so you buy a house. A WAY BIGGER AND NICER HOUSE than the apartment you were renting since, “it’s an investment.” ‎

Well GUESS WHAT: When you upgrade from a modest apartment to a big house the whole “rent vs buy” debate goes out the window. Because the associated expenses (insurance, taxes, maintenance, realtor fees, etc) go up relative to the size and value of the house!‎

The inverse is true too. If you’re renting a luxury apartment paying top dollar for all the amenities, you’re be way better off buying a modest home! The reduction in costs makes a way bigger difference than the small portion of your monthly housing expenses that actually goes towards the principle on your home (usually around 20% for most homeowners… 80% is a “thrown away”)‎

So stop worrying about whether you should rent or buy, worry about WHAT you’re renting or buying. Either way, keep it below your means so you can put more of your income into an actual investment (like index funds or investment real estate)!‎

As always, reminding you to build wealth by following the two PFC rules: 1.) Live below your means and 2.) Invest early and often.‎

-Jeremy‎

via Instagram

MORE POSTS

Rent vs Buy

The great debate: rent or buy?

Last night I had this great idea in the shower. I was going to make a post to illustrate the devastating impact of buying a house and selling sooner than five years. The crushing 6% realtor fee (huge relative to a 20% down payment), the missed opportunity cost of investing that down payment, the nefarious impact of taxes, insurance, maintenance, mortgage interest and closing costs. It would serve as an illustration of how the financial benefit of owning is really only reaped after many years of ownership.‎

How should I invest with my partner?

I wouldn’t call this an “optimal” investing plan. Notably, Valerie and Valentino decided to invest in a joint brokerage account, not individual Roth IRAs. Maybe

TAKE THE COURSE!

How to invest course

LET'S CONNECT

ABOUT

Jeremy Circle

Hi, I’m Jeremy! I retired at 36 and currently have a net worth of over $4 million. 

Personal Finance Club is here to give simple, unbiased information on how to win with money and become a multi-millionaire!